Tue 21 Apr 2009
Critical and Cynical: The Fine Line
Posted by Han Xian under General
No Comments
To me, there’s a fine line between being critical and a total cynic. Pastor Kong once preached about how some members in church run the risk of being cynical. I quite agree but on the other hand, I feel that this viewpoint should be taken with caution.
In my opinion, being a cynic means that you question just for the sake of questioning and the questions being posed have no basis or what we (as drama students) term as grounding. This is obviously not good one single bit because it just puts people off and I do not condone it either.
However, it is very common for people to take this message one (unnecessary) step further. This message is somehow commonly misinterpreted to the extent that they feel that people should just quit questioning and follow orders. I seriously don’t think this is what Pastor Kong actually meant. Our education system is now encouraging students to think and question critically and knowing pastor, I think he actually encourages that as well. So, I don’t think that he discourages questioning altogether.
That being said, however, one has to analyse whether his question has any basis or not because actually opening his mouth. It is no easy task and he has to bear the responsibility of the words that he utter. Still, that shouldn’t discourage a person from questioning something that actually has some grounding or truth to it. You might actually be doing some good than bad.
I actually believe that faith that is tested will emerge strong and grounded and grounded questioning is one way to do it = )